Overvalued Report
Five Receivers With Target Competition You're Ignoring
Odunze, Harrison Jr., Godwin, and Watson are priced for roles they don't have in crowded offenses.
September 2, 2026 · The Avid staff
The overvalued conversation has been living in the running back room all offseason, and that's fine — the RB cliff is real. But the mistakes that actually sink your season this year are wideouts, guys with brand-name recognition and target competition you're choosing to ignore. You draft the name, you get the committee. These are the receivers going too high relative to the role they'll actually run.
Rome Odunze, WR, CHI (5.06)
Odunze is going 5.06 in a Chicago room that just spent draft capital on Luther Burden III (5.06) and still has DJ Moore attached to it, plus a healthy tight end usage under Caleb Williams. That's three mouths ahead of or level with him for targets. A fifth-round price demands a defined No. 1 role, and Odunze doesn't have one locked.
At 5.06 I'd rather take Mike Evans one slot later at 5.07. You're paying almost the same pick for a proven touchdown machine with an unambiguous alpha role instead of a projection fighting two teammates for looks.
Marvin Harrison Jr., WR, ARI (6.04)
Harrison's sixth-round price is built on pedigree and the assumption of a leap. But the Arizona offense funnels through Trey McBride (3.05) as the primary target, and the ceiling here is capped by that. You're drafting the ADP that Harrison was supposed to grow into, not the one his usage justifies.
- ▸Marvin Harrison Jr. at 6.04 — target competition with a top-five TE
- ▸Michael Pittman Jr. at 7.04 — clearer role, cheaper price
- ▸Alec Pierce at 6.10 — same Indy passing game, half a round later
- ▸The gap between them isn't worth a full round of draft capital
I'd let Harrison slide and take Michael Pittman Jr. a round later at 7.04. Same tier of realistic outcome, and you bank the sixth-round pick on a running back or a tight end instead.
Chris Godwin Jr., WR, TB (7.07)
Godwin at 7.07 is a bet on a full return to form in a Tampa room that now has Emeka Egbuka (3.12) drafted well ahead of him. That's a signal. The market is telling you which Buccaneer it trusts, and it isn't Godwin. Paying a seventh for the clear No. 2 in his own offense is backwards.
Take Carnell Tate at 7.08 or Wan'Dale Robinson at 8.02 instead — younger upside or a defined slot role for a later pick. Both give you a cleaner path to targets than fighting Egbuka for them.
Christian Watson, WR, GB (5.10)
Watson's fifth-round tag is pure big-play tease in a Green Bay room that spreads it around as much as any in the league. Jayden Reed, Romeo Doubs, Matthew Golden and Tucker Kraft all eat, and the target share here has never consolidated. You're paying for ceiling weeks you can't schedule.
At 5.10 I'd take Courtland Sutton at 6.01 or wait a full round-plus and grab Matthew Golden at 9.12, who plays the same offense at a fraction of the cost. The volatility isn't worth a fifth-round pick.
Every one of these names shares the same flaw: you're buying the brand and inheriting the committee behind it.
How to play the WR middle
- ▸Fade receivers with two or more teammates ahead of them in target priority
- ▸Pay up only where the alpha role is unambiguous — Evans over Odunze
- ▸Push the reach a round later: Pittman over Harrison, Tate over Godwin
- ▸Turn the saved pick into a running back, where the scarcity is real
None of this is about hating the players. It's about the price. Odunze, Harrison, Godwin and Watson are all rosterable at the right cost — you just won't get them there if you draft them where the market says. Let someone else pay the name tax and take the guy one slot down with the clearer job.
The rankings behind this analysis update all season in the Draft Kit.
Get the 2026 Draft Kit — $19